Wine Advocate 89-91: Guigal's 2019 Chateauneuf du Pape again appears to play second fiddle to the house's Gigondas. Attractive floral. spice and cherry notes appear on the nose, while the full-bodied palate doesn't seem that rich or concentrated, and the finish is a bit chunky at this youthful stage.
James Suckling 94: Spicy and meaty with a very solid tannic base, this a serious Chateauneuf that has plenty of black fruit appeal, but also the muscular structure for long aging. Firm and focused finish with lots of energy and drive for this vintage. Drink or hold.
